Goodfellas Pizzeria Incorporated

Great time, great food, great service.

My favorite pizzeria

Got some pizza and wings last night. Said delivery would be about an hour and it was here in about half that. Delivery driver brought it right to our room great tasting pizza and solid wings. Did not realize it comes with blue cheese instead of ranch tho. But I wont dock then stars because of my ignorance. Good job fellas. If I can figure out how to add pictures I will.

We ordered delivery and it arrived fast and hot, got pizza and a steak taco! We would highly recommend. ( Just visiting from Iowa )

OMGGGGG they have the best wings ever I only order wings from they or else I won't eat them I love Goodfellas wings especially when Dottie is cooking them

Goodfellas always has good service and there pizza and wings are good.

Excellent pizza and the wings are big and full! The wings and half pizza deal is the best!

Had the chance to try these Fellas out when I visited from Canada. 10/10 probably the best pizza I've ever had in my life. Will be back!

Pizza and wings is great. If you are eating in the service is slow. You can see them just sitting around not doing much except socialize...

Was good a few years back. Trying the pizza wing combo again tonight

Very friendly place and the pizza is top notch.

Food is good and consistent. The little bar is nice to hang in while you wait. The area is a little sketchy so be careful.

Great pizza, fresh dough and toppings. You can get a wide variety of sizes for your party wether large or small. I typically get the half tray with wings and it is NEVER a disappointment!

Really good pizza and chicken fingers.Good staffChairs felt a little loose and the table was a little wobbly.

Excellent pizza and chicken wings food is outstanding service great

Pizza is delicious and CHEAP!

Best Pizza, Wings and Pitcher Deal in all of Canada & USA Niagara. Any food you order is fresh, hot and made to order. You will be back over and over. Awesome friendly staff. Free WiFi. Free Onsite Parking. Worth crossing the border for. Washrooms are small and dated. They appear to need repair and at times can be unkempt when busy.

My favorite pizza place in the city. Even when we moved away for some time everytime we visited we ate here as much as possible. When family visit this is where we always order our pizza and wings from.

One of the only pizza places open when we were looking for a late night snack. Found it through google. It didn't look like much, but the pizza was amazing. Only reason I didn't mark 5 stars was because of the wait.

Got pizza here the 1st day they opened 20+ years ago, and haven't stopped getting food there since!

It's Sunday, and we wanted a good Niagara Falls pizza. My wife grew up here. Pizza is a deeply held passion, with opinions running high. Two other places weren't open till 4 and 2. We were looking for a place to have a beer and turned into the Market to see what we could find. There was Goodfellas. On entering, we found 8 other family members. The pizza was awesome, and so were the wings. There was a special, so we got half a tray and 20 wings for $26. Who can argue with that? The pizza toppings were very generous. The wings were char-grilled, large, crispy, and well sauced. A winner!

Haven't been here in years, but when I did use to come the pizza was good. Well after all these years the pizza is still good, especially their char pitted wings. This pizza is the thicker (doughy) type crust that some people love or just hate it. I really enjoy it. You can eat inside the restaurant, but I strongly suggest you order out. As many others stated, this place is old and run down. I honestly believe, the only ones eating inside here is friends and family. There is also a bar area to catch a drink or two.

The food as always is good. I didn't appreciate having to wait an hour to get it. Not even ao much as "we're sorry for the delay ."

Really good food and nice people

Loved it, pizza was bigger than expected

Order from here often food is good service is excellent

Family owned and operated, this restaurant is an anchor of the City Market. A full menu, and a full service bar, are available. Thicker crust pizza with just the right amount of sauce with slices always available. They do offer delivery, but dine-in if you're a sports fan; there are always games on the TV.

Very nice place to sit and unwind

Always great pizza and wings!

Very good pizza. Lots of cheese. Great place to get delivery!! :)

While in Niagara Falls N.Y. , make it worth the while and ORDER from this place!!! One of the best pizza's we've ever had. And also got a meatball sub that was as equally as good if not better...

Goodfellas are very underated around here when, in fact, they have some of the best food

I love their pizza and wings. We order from here whenever i have cash to order... Wish they took card by phone though!!!

Great service and excellent pizza pie. Definitely reccomend Goodfellas. Wish they delivered to Niagara Falls Canada🇨🇦 lol ordering again next time we are back over the river

I think their food is very good. Always pretty fast paced and caring. Always accurate with orders and the customer service is awesome!!!

Great place for your pizza and wing needs. Food is always consistent and the service is good.

It's a great pizza.

This place is a dive, in all the best ways.It seems like a super hidden gem. Food is AMAZING. Seriously everything we ordered was top notch. And the portions are ridiculously huge. Staff is less so.

Pizza n wings= P E R F E C T I O N🎖Plus delivery guy was super nice so i tipped him, all-around GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE...

Great pizza and wings. Good value for the cost. Everytime I go to the US stop there for lunch.

Great food, atmosphere and friendly staff!

Besides great pizza..Dottie makes the best chicken soup..luv it

Love this place. Homemade sauce and wine, pizza was delicious! Must visit!

This place is kind of hidden but dont let that stop you from going. I had the large cheese steak and it was very good. I'm from out of town and I enjoy finding g good food places. This is one that I will certainly go back to when I'm back in town.